clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Rumors that Magic Johnson stepped down because Jeanie Buss accidentally shared emails where she and Rob Pelinka criticized his job performance are reportedly untrue

New, comments

As funny as the report that Jeanie Buss mistakenly blind cc’d Magic Johnson on critical emails from Rob Pelinka was, it sounds like that particular foray into Lakers rumors was untrue.

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

NBA: Golden State Warriors at Los Angeles Lakers Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY Sports

Earlier this week, there was a report — that we chose not to aggregate because we try to only bring you news from consistently reliable Lakers newsbreakers as much as possible — that Magic Johnson may have stepped down in part because Jeanie Buss accidentally cc’d him on emails between herself and general manager Rob Pelinka, messages that were critical of Johnson’s job performance with the Lakers.

You can read that report here, but before you do, you should consider that it has now been (seemingly) debunked by the far more reliable Bill Oram and Sam Amick of The Athletic:

The real reasons for Magic’s departure remain somewhat murky, but a source with knowledge of the situation adamantly denied the report indicating that Jeanie had mistakenly shared e-mails with Johnson that were critical of his job performance.

And let’s be real with ourselves for a minute: It always seemed unlikely that report was true. The Lakers have been painted as the picture of dysfunction over the several weeks since Johnson stepped down, but to imply this about their emails habits always seemed like a bit of an attempt at a pile on, because almost no one is dumb enough to accidentally loop a co-worker in on behind the scenes gossip, if those emails were even happening at all.

Come on. That’s like workplace 101! You think Christian and I cc Anthony when we complain about him on our email thread?

Look, on some level the Lakers have earned the laughing that people are doing at them over the last month or so, but if we’re going to poke fun at or criticize them, we should at least have it be over factual information. This report of emails does not seem to be that, so it’s only fair that we try to use this platform to inform people as much, just as we’d try to be upfront about it if there was a possibly unreliable rumor that was big enough that we had to acknowledge it here.

Because let’s be honest: If you want to be angry at — or laugh about — the Lakers, there are much better, factual reasons to do so right now, without implying that they’re brainless enough to accidentally share their burn book with the target of it.

For more Lakers talk, subscribe to the Silver Screen and Roll podcast feed on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher or Google Podcasts. You can follow Harrison on Twitter at @hmfaigen.