Should the Lakers shorten rotations without Andrew Bynum?
Once again, the Los Angeles Lakers find themselves in the unenviable position of having to deal with an injury to Andrew Bynum. The severity of the injury is not yet known; Bynum is scheduled to undergo an MRI right about now. Dex provided some good knowledge regarding strains in last night's recap, so check that out, but the general consensus is that Bynum is probably looking at anywhere from 2-6 weeks (a prognosis that will be much more specific after today). While this injury is probably not nearly as serious as previous episodes, it still has the potential to be just as damaging to the Lakers.
So now we must turn our attention to how the Lakers will respond strategically. I won't say this injury came at the worst possible time (unless it does actually take Bynum out for the playoffs, which is unlikely), but on a scale of "meh" to "We're f***ed", this is definitely a son of a bitch.
There are so many reasons this injury does significant damage to the Lakers. For one, Bynum has been playing his best, and most active, basketball of the season the past few weeks. There's been an energy level about his game that simply did not exist in previous versions, especially on the defensive end. Also, for the past few games (albeit against much inferior competition), we have finally seen strong performances from both Bynum and Pau Gasol, indicating that they have begun to reach a certain level of comfort in sharing the block. No matter how much time Bynum misses, there's no guarantee that he will be able to recapture that energy level and rhythm. Sadly, having seen this movie multiple times before, the storyline generally involves Bynum returning from injury and taking a long, long time to become fully comfortable on the court. This is definitely a different, less severe injury, so one can't say for sure that it will happen again, but we must prepare ourselves for the possibility that the Andrew Bynum which makes it to the playoffs will once again be a shell of the guy who was earning that $12 million a year.
But these reasons all deal with Bynum specifically. The question of how this affects the team overall is different altogether. This injury leaves the Lakers and Phil Jackson in a tight spot. On the one hand, the Lakers happen to employ the best backup big man in the league, so the quality of play won't suffer nearly as badly as if this were to happen to any other team in the league. But, after Lamar Odom, the drop off in talent is roughly akin to Niagra Falls. I love DJ Mbenga (and tolerate Josh Powell), but any time one of those players is on the court, it's bad news for the Lakers. DJ can defend well, but might actually be helping the other team on offense. Powell can stroke the shot sometimes, but not nearly as often as he tries to, and his defense is pretty deplorable. With the Lakers looking at a very difficult stretch of schedule (5 of the next 6 on the road), and with Dallas, Denver and Orlando all breathing down the Lakers necks fighting for potential home court advantage in the playoffs, Phil Jackson has to decide how much to play the two great bigs we have left.
Last season, when Bynum went down, Pau Gasol averaged 40 minutes a game the rest of the way. Considering how much we already believe Pau to be struggling with fatigue this season, that solution isn't very desired, but we may not have much of a choice. The Lakers can't even effectively go small (with Artest playing the 4 and Odom at the 5) because the depth at small forward is already razor thin without the services of Luke Walton. The Lakers have basically been playing a 9 man rotation, but of the 9 (starters + LO, Farmar, Brown, Sasha), 5 of those players are naturally guards. With Bynum's injury, we are down to 3 front court players for 3 front court positions, or else bringing in Powell and Mbenga to take up important minutes in important games.
So what would you do if you were Phil Jackson: Play Gasol more to keep the Lakers in a good groove? Play him the same and just suck it up with Mbenga and Powell? Would the length of Bynum's recovery change what PJ does? I'm looking at all these questions, and there are no clear answers. The only truth is this: No matter what the answers are, none of them are good.
0 recs |
125 comments
|
Comments
We should start Mbenga
and continue to bring Odom off the bench . The rotations would basically be the same as if Bynum were in there and we could easily Let Ron play the 4 and let Sasha man the 3 (he is 6’7) or Drop Kobe to the 3 and let Sasha play the 2 with limited minutes from Powell..The Lakers are very versatile in what they can do…Mbenga definitely brings a BIG physical presence in the paint and tries to swat every shot in the stands so im comfortable with him on D and he’ll know his role while on the court with Kobe and Gasol on offense, which should result in offensive boards and easy shots for him.
Kobe isnt good....He's just better than your favorite player
I'd be willing to try this but I don't you have to start your 5 best players?
--Conquest Chronicles, SBNation's USC Trojans blog
by Joey Kaufman on Mar 21, 2010 10:38 AM PDT up reply actions
We still start Fisher and he's not one of our 10 best players...
Kobe isnt good....He's just better than your favorite player
I have always wondered that too... It seems when he brings his game to another level an injury occurs.
Always kills me, its like two steps forward then six backwards with this kid.
its called being injury prone.
His body can’t handle what he’s trying to do.
Is that you Dacos?
Get well soon...
Luke coming back is a much more palatable solution than either Mbenga or Powell. Although either could play in spurts, to have to rely on them would be difficult at best. We may get away with it now and in the early rounds, but the deeper we get, the more this position would be exploited. With Luke we know what we get… not much, but never bad.
Pau’s not a banger, he relies heavily on Drew to carry this load, allowing him much greater freedom to work his man solo. A double on Pau spells potential doom for the Lakers. Can you picture Varejao, Shaq and Ilgauskas shutting down the middle? With Drew, we have a chance to neutralize their huge post presence, granted we make it to the Finals in the first place.
Let’s all send positive thoughts in Drew’s direction for a fast and speedy recovery.
we're not in a "win now mode"
so bring powell & mbenga off the bench (plus, we might need them during the playoffs if our bigs suddenly get into foul trouble—denver gets a lot of calls)
I have a friend who had Villanova going to the final four. He was soooooooo angry after the game, it was hilarious.
i went to highschool with the guy
that hit the dagger against kansas. hes a pretty laid back dude i think he was in my graduating class but i think he was a year older than me
YOU CAN PUT IT ON THE BOARD YES!
www.reverbnation.com/czheckproductions
And on the last day god made Kobe unstoppable,is it possible to stop something unstoppable?
yeaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
i got into that school
Samhan was unstoppable down low
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
I'm watching Ohio Tennessee right now
The Volunteers are a much grittier defensive team than Georgetown…nothing is coming easy…
its crazy how much success these double digit seeds are having
my bracket is so messed up right now
that would be crazy if murray st and ohio both won too
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
Achilles tendon
That is a bad, bad, bad, bad injury to have.
Bad injury.
Seriously bad.
All that said, the Lakers are better without him. Slightly.
One word: Odom.
Odom starts at C.
Do it, Pill. Do et.
Chupa! Chupa!
by DonaldSterlingSucks on Mar 20, 2010 1:19 PM PDT reply actions
I just posted Bynum's MRI results as a Fanpost
He seems to have no rupture and could miss only 4 games…nothing to worry about fellas.

"If you want to find the dumbest guy in the room just find the first guy to tell you how smart he is." - JG
by PURPLE AND GOLD FOR LIFE on Mar 20, 2010 1:41 PM PDT reply actions
I'm serious.
"If you want to find the dumbest guy in the room just find the first guy to tell you how smart he is." - JG
by PURPLE AND GOLD FOR LIFE on Mar 20, 2010 7:03 PM PDT up reply actions
Should be worried a little bit...achilles injuries can re-aggravate without proper care
I know from playing soccer for 15 years. When he comes back he has to make sure to control his lift and planting foot. This is the best news out of a bad situation.
by GRICE on Mar 20, 2010 1:50 PM PDT reply actions
we shall then let give him lots of rest
like we did with gasol. like you said these injuries are very treatable but if you rush him back, you run the risk of more damage such as a tear and with the playoffs approaching, we cant afford to take any chances with him.
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
Looking at the schedule, I'd like to see Drew back April 2 v. Utah or April 4 v. Spurs
2 week rest or 3 weeks. I want Drew back as well…Achilles injuries are really tricky. I don’t want to sound repetitive. Rest up 17.
by GRICE on Mar 20, 2010 2:02 PM PDT reply actions
Lol shorten our rotation? TRY make our rotation bigger
I know its important to get people in a rhthym in time for the playoffs, but you also don’t want to go into the playoffs tired and injured…. I’d like to see us try to coast up until april at least.. before playing our guys major minutes
In Kobe we trust!
Well...
At least the game didn’t end in heartbreaking fashion. Ohio in trouble after an 18-2 blitz in the first half. Tennessee would never let them into the game after that. The Volunteers played as good a defensive game as you can imagine, with lots of steals and shot blocks leading to fast break points. And the Bobcats didn’t get any points from their bench.
I guess what I’m trying to say is…Tennessee’s a pretty good team. Ohio…not so much. Sigh…
i smell an upset
for the Huskies
Im not sure how long Northern Iowa can keep it up…
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
Holy shit Kansas!!!
this is gonna be epic if this happens….
WOW EPIC FAIL
wow this is a CLASSIC choke job
i know, they were just BEGGING to give that ball back to KU
this is crazy shit
by desecrator09 on Mar 20, 2010 4:48 PM PDT up reply actions
its an insult to call northern iowa "iowa"
the university of iowa had such a bad 3 years we had to fire our coach. go panthers
YOU CAN PUT IT ON THE BOARD YES!
www.reverbnation.com/czheckproductions
And on the last day god made Kobe unstoppable,is it possible to stop something unstoppable?
i went to high school with that kid
YOU CAN PUT IT ON THE BOARD YES!
www.reverbnation.com/czheckproductions
And on the last day god made Kobe unstoppable,is it possible to stop something unstoppable?
The Lakers could sign Michael Fey to a 10-day contract.
He made it through most of training camp before being cut. Otherwise the Lakers should be fine.
lets see
St Mary’s over Nova
Northern Iowa over Kansas
Washington over New Mexico
wowowowowowowow…
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
ehhh, i just thought new mexico was overrated
overseeded at least
by desecrator09 on Mar 20, 2010 4:57 PM PDT up reply actions
yeah but they are absloutely toruncing them
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
Marquette matched up well with the Huskies. Plus their coach is good with X's and O's.
New Mexico aren’t athletic at all as a team. Washington is athletic AND have skills to match. I think they’ll continue to give opposing teams fits. I think Syracuse is in trouble.
pretty much
virtually everyone had Kansas in the final four
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
at least my Baylor bears are still alive
have them in my final four
Hey, look at the bright side
This game might have destroyed Sherron Collins’ draft stock to the point that we might be able to pick him up in the second round. <.<
To secure ourselves against defeat lies in our own hands, but the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself.
True. Collins has been struggling the last couple of games.
Hopefully, scouts bad-mouth him to oblivion. :-)
I wouldn't worry about Reynolds
If we want him, we’ll get him with our first second rounder. I’d wager he’d still be available for the 59th pick in any case.
To secure ourselves against defeat lies in our own hands, but the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself.
I have NEVER! understood how one game can effect a player's "stock"
I would think that scouts could think of it in terms “hey, everyone has a bad game” Is it that if a player doesn’t perform in the tournament that it’s an indication that he won’t handle the NBA? That has always surprised me.
"If you want to find the dumbest guy in the room just find the first guy to tell you how smart he is." - JG
by PURPLE AND GOLD FOR LIFE on Mar 20, 2010 7:37 PM PDT up reply actions
This is the best competition they face and the biggest stage they can perform on
Performing badly tends not to reflect well on the individual player, especially one who already had an uncertain draft stock beforehand. There’s only so much one can discern from workouts, the combine, and interviews — you need actual competition to see how they perform. The draft is already a crapshoot in general, so giving scouts more reason not to like you is a death knell for your stock, as you’ve just raised a couple more questions for a prospective GM.
Collins is undersized, turnover prone, and a senior, so this was his big chance to raise his stock and get into the first round. He just blew that chance entirely, although I’d wager someone takes a flier on him before us simply because of the lack of point guard prospects in the draft.
To secure ourselves against defeat lies in our own hands, but the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself.
Thnx for the response
Not surprised at how much you know. I never look at the sport through an intellectual lense only from how “passionate” a player looks. Just like J. Noah. Always thought he would be a good player because of how emotional he plays. But in terms of stats and performance that is tough for me to gauge. Thnx for the break down.
"If you want to find the dumbest guy in the room just find the first guy to tell you how smart he is." - JG
by PURPLE AND GOLD FOR LIFE on Mar 20, 2010 10:16 PM PDT up reply actions
Noah was on two straight NCAA championship teams
And was the MOP of the second. The statistics and performance were definitely there to base positive projections on.
To secure ourselves against defeat lies in our own hands, but the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself.
Oh, never mind, completely misinterpreted your post
To secure ourselves against defeat lies in our own hands, but the opportunity of defeating the enemy is provided by the enemy himself.
Wow how come AMMO is not mentioned in this post?
He’ll be our savior. No wonder they say lakers fans know shit about basketball. Im disappointed C.A.
Is that you Dacos?
sigh to andrew's injury, but great post :)
Just an ordinary 9th grade Lakers fan.
Bynum
There are some easy options if he is out a short time you could use Artest at PF and move Kobe to the SF using Brown and Fisher or Farmar. Or if his shot comes back use Sasha and play Kobe at the SF more. Bynum was playing better I have never liked him and Gasol together I think they clog up seems and cause congestion in the middle.
My Final 4 Picks:
Duke vs. Kentucky
Kansas State vs. Syracuse
Finals:
Syracuse vs. Duke
Duke win xD
"That's a giant sig " - Ben R.
wow all chalk??
And kansas st and Syracuse are in the same bracket so both wont be in the final four lol. come on man, theres been upsets all over the place this year. No way all those teams will make it. I got Kansas st, Baylor, Ohio st, and west virginia.
by desecrator09 on Mar 20, 2010 10:13 PM PDT up reply actions
Yeah I was just about to comment I see Ohio State making it through, actually
Baylor over Duke? C’mon. Considering St Mary’s just upset Nova, there’s no guarantee Baylor even make it to playing Duke =]]
"That's a giant sig " - Ben R.
by Saurav A. Das on Mar 20, 2010 10:16 PM PDT up reply actions
also no guarentee Duke gets past Cal
goin by that logic
by desecrator09 on Mar 20, 2010 10:49 PM PDT up reply actions
Yes, but I'm a Duke homer, so I gotta represent.
:P
"That's a giant sig " - Ben R.
by Saurav A. Das on Mar 20, 2010 11:35 PM PDT up reply actions
no it'll go like this
it will be
Duke Vs UK(go cats :P)
Kansas State vs. Syracuse
Finals :
Kansas state vs. UK
UK wins it all
kansas st and syracuse CANT BE IN THE FOUR!
they in the same bracket
by desecrator09 on Mar 21, 2010 2:55 PM PDT up reply actions
im predicting these teams for the final four:
Kentucky
Duke
Syracuse
Ohio State
Syracuse is a tossup. Either them or Kansas State. IMO Ohio State is a lock since Kansas got upset…
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
If Ohio State make the Final Four, it can only help Evan Turner's prospects to be #1 pick before WAll
However slim those prospects remain.
"That's a giant sig " - Ben R.
Solution: Kobe Bryant pick it up
would have been a sure shot, no-question thing back in December when he was healthy… Get back in the post, and obliterate whoever is guarding him down there (only on the opposite side of the floor is Pau and not Drew)
Can’t wait for Kobe to pick it up as they head to the playoffs. I hope he picks it up real good, and that finger goes to hell. ;>
Poor evan turner has to carry so much more of the load today
He only scored 9 points vs Santa Barbara. Today he’s scored 14 of his team’s 21 points.
that midwest bracket is WIDE open now
just imagine how good georgia tech would be if they actually had guards who can get the ball to Favors and Lawell consistently
by desecrator09 on Mar 21, 2010 12:30 PM PDT up reply actions
Ohio State isn't playing that well today
Turner and Lightly are doing all the work. Diebler’s having a bad game. And their bench has given them next to nothing.
I'd say watch out Buckeyes
I think Tennessee has a chance in that one
--Conquest Chronicles, SBNation's USC Trojans blog
by Joey Kaufman on Mar 21, 2010 1:39 PM PDT up reply actions
nope
this really is the worst weekend ever for me
march madness is helping me though stay distracted…
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
well...
Ive been waiting for two months to hear from my top choice college. Everyone else around me was getting in some as early as February. Then yesterday morning, I got an email from them saying I got rejected. Its a lot like being the one kid who gets coal in his stocking while everyone else get presents. Ruined my entire weekend. Now Im really not sure where I’ll go. I will probably hear from my last three colleges soon and I dont feel very confident at all that I will get into them.
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
how awful
and they never tell you what it was they were looking for that you lacked next to people who were chosen.
You know, I might not end up going to graduate school after all. Even though I was accepted, I still need a teaching assistantship to pay for out-of-state tuition and living expenses. Unfortunately, the school’s budget is smaller than ever before, and more people are applying than ever before, so I may not get one, even though I might have in a different year.
UCI
i really thought I would get in. My grades and etc were in the range. Everyday in between classes I would go to a computer and login to my account to see if they made a decision. Hearing from other people that they got in over the last few weeks makes me absolutely sick.
"Just by the aura of D.J. Mbenga being there, the shot missed."
bah, if a college rejects you...
then you are too good for them. it’s not your loss, it’s their’s.
that’s the way you should look at it.
don’t get too hung up on it because you never know what’s going to happen in the future. college is about meeting the right people. going to a different college doesn’t mean the people you meet will be any less great people while going to your top choice doesn’t guarantee that you’ll meet great people.
np. hope you feel better :)
i’ve gotten plenty of rejections from schools. :)
I know getting over it is easier said than done, but when you look in retrospect, it’s not that bad, really. look foward to “what could be” and not “what could’ve been”.
right now, there’s just not much you can do…so enjoy senioritis because it’s once in a lifetime :)

by 
































